A Gay Girl in Damascus
During the Syrian uprising a blog by a gay Syrian woman drew international attention, and her reported abduction drew a campaign. She had been invented by a 40-year-old American man, using photographs of a woman in London who knew nothing about it.
Why this verdict
Debunked and confessed: the Syrian lesbian blogger reported abducted in 2011 did not exist, and the blog was written throughout by an American postgraduate student in Edinburgh.
- Period
- Region
- Reading time
- Sources
01The claim
That Amina Abdallah Arraf al Omari, a Syrian-American lesbian writing the blog A Gay Girl in Damascus, was documenting the uprising from inside Damascus, and that on 6 June 2011 she was seized by armed men — a claim posted by a cousin and taken up as an international campaign.
02Where it came from
The blog began in February 2011 as the uprising spread, and was quickly cited by major outlets as a rare first-person account from a doubly vulnerable position. Its author was Tom MacMaster, an American graduate student living in Edinburgh, who had begun the persona to write about Middle Eastern politics with an authority he did not have. The abduction post was written by MacMaster as the fictional cousin.
03What the record shows
✕ DEBUNKED — Investigated and refuted. Here is what actually happened.
The unravelling took under a week and was done by people the hoax had recruited.
Supporters organising a campaign for Amina's release tried to verify her existence and could not: no consulate had a record, no one had met her, and activists in Damascus who should have known of her did not. The photographs on the blog were identified as pictures of Jelena Lecic, a woman living in London who had never heard of the blog and who had to appear on the BBC to say the face being circulated as an abducted Syrian was hers.
Technical tracing did the rest: the blog's IP activity resolved to Edinburgh. MacMaster posted an apology on the blog on 12 June 2011 and confirmed his authorship, writing that he did not believe he had hurt anyone — a judgment the record does not support.
The hoax had a second-order casualty. Lez Get Real, a site that had published Amina's work, was found during the same scramble to have its own fabricated identity: its founder, presenting as a deaf lesbian woman, was a married man in Ohio. Two of the most-cited lesbian voices in that news cycle were men.
04What it cost
The damage was concrete and fell on people already in danger. Syrian activists spent days of a lethal uprising campaigning for a person who did not exist, and several said publicly that the exposure made Western journalists warier of the anonymous accounts that were, at that point, the only channel out of parts of the country. LGBT Syrians — who had real reason to fear identification — became harder to source and easier to dismiss. MacMaster's stated intent was to draw attention to Syria; the mechanism he chose made the attention retractable.