THE ARCHIVE

Verdict view

105 debunked entries

The largest section, and the one that gets the same typographic care as the others. Each entry states the claim fairly before refuting it, because a debunk that sneers is a debunk that loses.

The standard applied

The central claim has been tested against physical evidence, documents, or investigation and fails. Where the claim is unfalsifiable by construction, that is stated as part of the refutation.

VerdictDEBUNKED
DEBUNKED

2019–2021 · Global

5G and COVID-19

A claim that 5G networks caused or spread COVID-19 circulated in early 2020 and led to more than a hundred arson attacks on telecommunications masts in Europe. Several of the burned masts were not 5G. One was serving a hospital.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2001–2008 · United States

9/11 controlled demolition

The towers fell because fire weakened steel that was already carrying loads redistributed by the impacts. The specific claims — molten steel, free-fall, symmetrical collapse, thermite — have each been examined by structural engineers and answered. The unanswered questions about 11 September 2001 are political, not structural.

Government & Intelligence · 4 min

DEBUNKED

2011 · Syria / United Kingdom

A Gay Girl in Damascus

During the Syrian uprising a blog by a gay Syrian woman drew international attention, and her reported abduction drew a campaign. She had been invented by a 40-year-old American man, using photographs of a woman in London who knew nothing about it.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2014–2017 · United States

A Rape on Campus

A 2014 magazine account of a gang rape at a University of Virginia fraternity collapsed within months. A police investigation found no basis for it, and an outside review commissioned by the magazine called it an avoidable failure at every stage.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1955–2013 · United States

Area 51 and the alien bodies

Area 51 is real, was secret for decades, and the CIA has now published its history. It was built to test the U-2 and its successors. The alien reverse-engineering story rests almost entirely on one man whose academic record cannot be found.

Space & Aviation · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2017–2024 · United States

Birds Aren't Real

A movement claiming that the US government replaced every bird with surveillance drones was invented on the spot in 2017 as a joke. Its founder has been explicit about this in interviews. It nonetheless acquired merchandise, rallies and billboards.

Modern Internet-Era · 2 min

DEBUNKED

1996–2024 · Global

Chemtrails

Aircraft exhaust contains water vapour. At altitude, in humid enough air, it forms ice clouds that persist and spread. The variation people notice tracks humidity, not policy — and the atmospheric chemists best placed to detect a covert programme report finding none.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2009–2012 · United Kingdom / United States

Climategate

Thousands of emails stolen from a British climate research unit weeks before the Copenhagen summit, presented as proof that the temperature record was fabricated. Eight inquiries found no fabrication. The phrases that made the story famous meant something other than what they were said to mean.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1978–2024 · United Kingdom

Crop circles

Two Englishmen in a pub decided in 1978 to make a flying saucer landing site with a plank and a rope. Thirteen years later they demonstrated the method to journalists. Crop circles are now commissioned as advertising.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1995–2024 · United States

Denver International Airport

An airport that opened sixteen months late and $2 billion over budget, decorated with strange murals and a demonic-looking horse, in the middle of the plains. Every element of the mythology has a mundane and checkable origin, most of them documented by the airport's own archives.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1997–2024 · Germany / Poland

Die Glocke

A secret Nazi device said to have produced anti-gravity or time-distortion effects. Every account traces to one 1997 book, whose evidence is a transcript its author says he was allowed to read but not keep.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1936–2003 · United States

Drake's Plate of Brass

A brass plate claiming California for Elizabeth I, found in 1936 and treated for forty years as the oldest English artefact in the American West. It was a practical joke by a fraternity of history enthusiasts, aimed at one professor, that got away from them.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1977–2024 · Global

Faked celebrity deaths

Elvis Presley, Tupac Shakur, Jim Morrison, Michael Jackson and dozens of others have all been claimed to be alive. Each claim is anchored in documents and rests on an argument that no evidence can disturb.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1838–2024 · Global

Flat Earth

The Earth's shape was measured to within a few percent in the third century BC and has been confirmed by every method since. Modern flat-Earth belief is not a survival of ancient cosmology; it is a twenty-first-century community built on distrust of institutions.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1945–2024 · United States

Fluoridation as mind control

The claim that fluoride was added to water to pacify populations dates to 1950s anti-communist pamphleteering. The dental benefit is real and measured. The dosing question has been revised downward on evidence, which is what a health policy is supposed to do.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1931–1939 · Isle of Man

Gef the talking mongoose

A farming family on the Isle of Man reported in 1931 that a talking mongoose lived in their walls. Two well-known psychical researchers investigated. The hair sample came from the family dog.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1993–2024 · United States

HAARP

HAARP is a real ionospheric research array in Alaska, once military-funded, now run by a university and open to visitors. The claim that it steers hurricanes and triggers earthquakes fails on the numbers by many orders of magnitude.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1692–2024 · Global

Hollow Earth

The idea that the Earth contains a habitable interior reached by polar openings was a respectable hypothesis in 1692 and an expedition proposal in 1818. Seismic tomography settled it. We have, in effect, an X-ray of the planet.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2000–2009 · United States

John Titor

An anonymous poster claimed in 2000 to be a soldier sent back from 2036 for an IBM 5100. He made dated, checkable predictions. They were wrong, and a single author was later identified.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1999–2001 · United States

Kaycee Nicole

For two years an online community followed a teenager's illness and grieved her death. She had never existed. The people who worked it out did so by asking for an address to send flowers.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1958–2017 · Northern Ireland

Kincora

Boys were abused at a Belfast children's home and three staff were convicted in 1981. The enduring claim is that British intelligence knew and allowed it, to blackmail visitors. An inquiry with access to the files did not find that.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2021–2024 · United States

Litter boxes in schools

A claim that schools were providing litter boxes for pupils who identify as cats travelled from a Michigan school board meeting to the floor of state legislatures. Every named instance dissolved on contact. The one real thing underneath it is a school-shooting supply.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1973–1974 · United States

Lost Boy Larry

In August 1973 a child's voice came over citizens' band radio saying he was trapped in a crashed truck with his dead father. It was heard as far as California. One of the largest searches in American history found nothing.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2006–2023 · Global

Miracle Mineral Supplement

A solution that becomes chlorine dioxide when mixed as instructed, sold as a cure for HIV, cancer, malaria, autism and COVID-19, with the claim that regulators suppress it because it is cheap. People have died. Its distributors were convicted.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1946–2024 · Global

Modern weather control

Weather modification exists, is licensed, and produces effects at the edge of detectability. The gap between that and directing a hurricane is roughly the gap between a garden hose and a river — and every major flood now produces a wave of claims that someone did it deliberately.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2002–2024 · United States

Morgellons

People report fibres emerging from their skin, along with crawling sensations and lesions, and are told by doctors that no infection is present. The distress is genuine and the condition is recognised clinically. What is not supported is the claim that a pathogen is being covered up.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1995–2024 · Global

Nibiru / Planet X

A large planet supposedly on a collision course with Earth has had its arrival date moved at least a dozen times since 2003. If it existed at the distances claimed, it would be one of the brightest objects in the sky.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1961–2024 · Global

Out-of-place artefacts

A category of objects said to be found in impossible strata, proving a lost advanced civilisation that orthodox archaeology refuses to acknowledge. Each object has been examined. None of them is what the claim needs it to be.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1969–1970 · United Kingdom / United States

Paul is dead

A rumour that Paul McCartney died in 1966 and was replaced by a lookalike spread across American campus radio in 1969. McCartney is alive. The clues were found by people who had already decided to look.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1912–1953 · United Kingdom

Piltdown Man

For forty years the missing link between ape and man was an English gravel pit. The jaw was an orangutan's, stained and filed. One man almost certainly did all of it alone.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2016–2017 · United States

Pizzagate

A claim that a Washington pizzeria housed a child trafficking operation in its basement was assembled from hacked emails in October 2016. Six weeks later a man drove 350 miles and fired an assault rifle inside the restaurant. There is no basement.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1950–2024 · Philippines / Brazil / Global

Psychic surgery

Practitioners appear to open a patient's body with their hands, remove diseased tissue and leave no wound. The tissue is chicken. The technique is sleight of hand, and it is sold to people with terminal diagnoses.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2017–2022 · United States

QAnon

An anonymous poster claiming high-level clearance promised a wave of mass arrests that never came. The movement is falsifiable in a way most conspiracy theories are not — it made specific predictions with dates — and it failed every one.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1979–2024 · Global

Red mercury

A substance said to allow briefcase-sized nuclear weapons, traded on black markets since the late 1980s at millions of dollars a kilogram. It does not exist. The trade in it is real, and has been used as bait by security services.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1988–2024 · Global

Reptilians

The claim that shapeshifting reptilian beings occupy positions of power has produced no evidence of any kind. Its most influential version substitutes lizards for the cast of an older antisemitic conspiracy narrative, which is the most important fact about it.

Cults & Movements · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1947–1997 · United States

Roswell

Something secret did crash near Roswell in 1947, and the military did cover it up. It was a balloon train carrying acoustic sensors designed to listen for Soviet atomic tests. The alien version was assembled thirty years later.

Space & Aviation · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2012–2022 · United States

Sandy Hook denial

Twenty children and six staff were murdered at an elementary school in Connecticut in December 2012. The claim that it was staged has been tested in open court twice and lost, and the families who brought those cases had spent a decade being hunted.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1861–1932 · United States / United Kingdom

Spirit photography

For seventy years photographers sold portraits with the sitter's dead relatives standing behind them. The medium was new enough that its failure modes looked like the afterlife. It was double exposure, and the market for it was grief.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2016–2023 · United States

Spygate — the Russia investigation's origins

The claim that the FBI's Russia investigation was manufactured by officials to sabotage a candidate. Two adversarial reviews looked for the plot and did not find one. Both found significant misconduct of a different kind, which the claim tends to swallow.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1920–1930 · Germany / France / United Kingdom / United States

The 'Black Horror on the Rhine'

A campaign of the 1920s alleging that African soldiers in the French occupation force were raping and mutilating German women on a mass scale. Investigators found the crimes did not exist. The campaign ran for a decade anyway, in four countries.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1981–2023 · Global

The aspartame cover-up

A chain email circulated from the 1990s attributing multiple sclerosis, lupus and blindness to a sweetener, and a corrupt approval to Donald Rumsfeld. The disease list is fabricated. The regulatory history is real, contested in public, and more interesting than the conspiracy version.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2001–2006 · Czech Republic / Iraq / United States

The Atta–Prague meeting

The claim that the lead 9/11 hijacker met an Iraqi intelligence officer in Prague in April 2001 — the single most-cited link between Saddam Hussein and the attacks. It came from one informant, and it does not survive Atta's paper trail.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1963–2026 · United States

The Badge Man

A shape in a Polaroid taken at the instant John F. Kennedy was shot, identified in 1982 as a police officer firing from behind the fence on the grassy knoll. At that magnification the photograph contains no information at all.

Assassinations · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1889–2004 · United States

The Bat Creek Stone

An inscribed tablet from a Tennessee burial mound, promoted since the 1970s as proof that Hebrew speakers reached America before Columbus. The letters were copied out of a Freemasonry dictionary.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1942–1983 · United States

The Battle of Los Angeles

Anti-aircraft batteries fired more than 1,400 shells over Los Angeles one night in 1942. Nothing was shot down and no aircraft was ever found. The photograph everyone knows was retouched by a newspaper, as was standard practice.

Space & Aviation · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1885–1982 · United States

The Beale ciphers

Three ciphertexts said to give the location of a buried fortune in Bedford County, Virginia. One decodes with the Declaration of Independence. The other two have resisted 140 years of attack — most likely because there is nothing in them.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1950–2024 · North Atlantic

The Bermuda Triangle

Lloyd's of London and the US Coast Guard both report no unusual loss rate in the area. The famous disappearances turn out to involve storms, fuel exhaustion, and in several cases ships that sank somewhere else entirely.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2015–2020 · United States / Ukraine

The Biden–Ukraine claim

The claim that Joe Biden forced out a Ukrainian prosecutor to protect his son's employer. The prosecutor's removal was allied policy, urged for the opposite reason, and the case in question was not active.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1958–2024 · North America

The Bigfoot cover-up

Every hair, bone and tissue sample ever submitted for testing has returned as a known animal or as human. The footprints that started the modern era were made with carved wooden feet, and the family that made them kept them.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2005–2024 · Bosnia and Herzegovina

The Bosnian pyramids

A businessman announced in 2005 that hills near Visoko were the world's oldest and largest pyramids. Geologists identified them as natural flatirons. The excavation has damaged a genuine medieval royal town on the same hill.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1943–2001 · United States

The Camp Van Dorn slaughter

A 1998 self-published book alleged that 1,200 Black soldiers were machine-gunned by white troops at a Mississippi camp in 1943 and buried in a mass grave. The regiment's men were subsequently found alive, in Army records and in person.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1995–2024 · Latin America / United States

The chupacabra

A blood-draining creature reported in Puerto Rico in 1995 and later across the Americas, sometimes attributed to secret government genetic experiments. The bodies keep turning out to be mangy coyotes. The first description came from a film.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1993–2024 · United States

The Clinton body count

A circulating list attributes dozens of deaths to the Clintons. It is built by counting anyone who ever met them, over forty years, and treating each death as suspicious. Applied to any long career, the method produces the same result.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1762–1763 · United Kingdom

The Cock Lane ghost

A London ghost that knocked out answers and accused a man of murdering her by poison. A committee went down to the crypt to ask her to knock on her own coffin. She did not.

Cults & Movements · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1917–1983 · United Kingdom

The Cottingley Fairies

Five photographs taken by two girls in a Yorkshire village in 1917. Arthur Conan Doyle published them as evidence that fairies exist. The figures were traced from a gift book they had at home.

Cults & Movements · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1990–2024 · Global

The deep state

The phrase describes something real when applied to states like Turkey, where a documented clandestine network operated inside the security services. Applied to the United States as a unified hidden authority, it fails: what exists is a large, slow, internally hostile bureaucracy that leaks constantly.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1919–1925 · United States

The Elaine 'insurrection' claim

White Arkansans killed somewhere between two hundred and eight hundred Black people in 1919 and explained it as the suppression of an insurrection. The insurrection was a meeting of sharecroppers about cotton prices, and a lawyer.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1982–2019 · United Kingdom

The Elm Guest House allegations

A list naming prominent British men as abusers at a south London guest house, and a witness the police called credible and true. The list came from a convicted fraudster and the witness was fabricating. The Metropolitan Police apologised.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1977–1979 · United Kingdom

The Enfield poltergeist

Eighteen months of knocking, moving furniture and a gruff voice in a London council house in 1977. The children admitted to pranking. The investigators told them to take it back.

Cults & Movements · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1999 · Canada / United Kingdom / Australia / New Zealand / Ireland

The freeman-on-the-land theory

The belief that statute law binds you only if you consent, and that a secret second legal person created at your birth is the thing the state actually taxes and prosecutes. The arguments are sold by seminar. They have never once worked.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1980–2022 · United States

The Georgia Guidestones

A granite monument in rural Georgia carried ten precepts in eight languages, the first of which mentioned maintaining humanity under 500 million. It was commissioned anonymously in 1979 by a private individual. It was bombed in 2022 and demolished the same day.

Cults & Movements · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1835 · United States

The Great Moon Hoax of 1835

In 1835 the New York Sun published six articles describing bison, bipedal beavers and winged humanoids observed on the Moon through a new telescope. Circulation soared. The astronomer credited with the discoveries knew nothing about it.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2017–2019 · United States

The grievance studies affair

Three writers spent a year submitting deliberately absurd papers to humanities journals. Seven were accepted. What the exercise proves has been argued about ever since, largely because it was designed without anything to compare the result against.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1987–1990 · United States

The Gulf Breeze UFO photographs

A Florida building contractor produced the most-published UFO photographs of the 1980s. A model matching them was found in the attic of the house he had just sold.

Space & Aviation · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1964–2002 · India / Himalayas

The Himalayan fossil hoax

Twenty-five years and 458 papers on the geology of the Himalayas, built on fossils that came from other continents. The reconstruction of an entire mountain range's deep history had to be dismantled.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1890–2004 · India / United States / United Kingdom

The Indian rope trick

A rope thrown into the air that stands rigid, a boy who climbs it and vanishes. It was invented by a Chicago newspaperman in 1890 for a story he made up, and the Tribune said so the same year.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2001–2005 · United States / Iraq

The Iraqi aluminium tubes

Aluminium tubes intercepted en route to Iraq were presented as evidence of a reconstituted nuclear programme. The government's own nuclear laboratories said they were for artillery rockets. The public case did not mention that.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1956–2006 · France

The Jesus bloodline and the Priory of Sion

The secret society said to guard a bloodline was registered as a small club in a French village in 1956 by a man who later admitted, under oath, to inventing its history and forging the parchments deposited in the national library.

Cults & Movements · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1898–2024 · United States

The Kensington Runestone

A stone found in a Minnesota field in 1898 records a Norse expedition in 1362. Its language is the Swedish of the people who found it, not of the century it names.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2004–2005 · United States

The Killian documents

Six memos said to be from George W. Bush's National Guard commander, aired by CBS two months before the 2004 election. Within hours the typography was being taken apart online. Within two weeks CBS had abandoned them.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1951–1998 · Korea / China / Soviet Union

The Korean War biological warfare allegations

China and North Korea alleged in 1952 that the United States was dropping plague-infected insects on Korea. Captured American airmen confessed. The Soviet files record the whole thing as a fabrication and describe how it was assembled.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2014–2016 · United States

The LaCour canvassing study

A celebrated study found that a short conversation with a gay canvasser durably changed minds on same-sex marriage. The data was invented. The finding was then partially vindicated by researchers who did the work properly — which is the part worth knowing.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1716–2024 · England

The last witch executed in England

Reference works have long named Mary Hicks and her nine-year-old daughter as the last people hanged for witchcraft in England, in 1716. Historians who went looking for the trial found no trial.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1866–2026 · United States

The Lost Cause of the Confederacy

The account of the American Civil War in which the South fought for states' rights, slavery was benign and incidental, and defeat came only from numbers. It was assembled deliberately after 1865 and taught from textbooks vetted for it.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1960–1990 · Soviet Union

The Lost Cosmonauts

The claim that cosmonauts died in orbit before Gagarin and were erased. The Soviet space programme did conceal deaths and did airbrush people out of pictures, which is why this took hold. The specific claim still fails.

Space & Aviation · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2009–2024 · Global

The Mandela Effect as conspiracy

Large numbers of people share the same false memory. That much is true and has been demonstrated in the laboratory for decades. The claim that this indicates timeline manipulation is answered by the fact that psychologists can create the effect deliberately.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1770–1857 · Austria / Europe / United States

The Mechanical Turk

A chess-playing automaton that toured Europe and America for eighty-five years, beat Napoleon and Benjamin Franklin, and provoked the first serious public argument about whether a machine could think. There was a man inside the whole time.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2018–2019 · Global

The Momo Challenge

A claim that a WhatsApp account with a grotesque avatar was instructing children to hurt themselves swept schools and news bulletins in early 2019. No verified victim was ever found. The warnings were the thing that spread.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1983–2024 · United States

The Montauk Project

A decommissioned radar station on Long Island is said to have hosted experiments in mind control, teleportation and time travel. The account comes from one man's recovered memories, and the sequel to a story that was already admitted to be invented.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1969–2024 · United States

The Moon landing hoax

The claim that Apollo was staged has been answered by evidence that does not depend on trusting NASA: lasers bounced off mirrors left on the Moon, rock samples that cannot be made on Earth, and photographs of the hardware taken by other countries' spacecraft.

Space & Aviation · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1889–2024 · United States

The Nampa figurine

A small clay figure said to have come up from 320 feet down an Idaho well shaft in 1889, offered as proof of humans in the Pliocene. The depth is the whole claim, and the depth is unverified.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1741–1742 · United States

The New York conspiracy of 1741

A series of fires in Manhattan in 1741 became a plot to burn the city. Thirty-four people were executed, thirteen burned at the stake, on evidence produced by a court that paid for accusations.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1860–2024 · United States

The Newark Holy Stones

Hebrew-inscribed stones found in Ohio's ancient earthworks in 1860, offered as proof that the mound builders were Israelites. The lettering is nineteenth-century. The argument they were made to settle was about slavery.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2004–2016 · United States

The Obama religion claim

A claim that Barack Obama concealed being Muslim ran through two presidential campaigns and, at its peak, was believed by nearly a fifth of Americans. The record was never in doubt. The claim's function was never really about religion.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1991–2024 · Europe

The phantom time hypothesis

A German writer proposed in 1991 that the years 614 to 911 were fabricated and never happened. Tree rings, eclipse records from three civilisations and Halley's Comet all disagree.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1943–1984 · United States

The Philadelphia Experiment

A destroyer escort was supposedly made invisible and teleported in 1943, with crewmen fused into the hull. The ship's own logs show it was not in Philadelphia. The single source for the story wrote letters in green ink under a false name.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1992–2008 · Democratic Republic of the Congo / Global

The polio vaccine AIDS hypothesis

The claim that HIV entered humans through a polio vaccine trialled in the Congo in the late 1950s. The vaccine was tested and was clean, and the virus is older than the trial.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1820–1894 · United States

The Pompey stone

A carved stone dug up in upstate New York in 1820, read for seventy years as evidence that Europeans had reached the region by 1520. Two relatives of a local engineer had cut it and put it in the ground as a joke.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1984–1988 · United States

The salamander letter

A letter that rewrote the founding story of the Latter-day Saint movement, sold to collectors and to the church itself. Its author had made it. When exposure came close he killed two people with pipe bombs.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1980–1995 · United States / Canada / United Kingdom

The satanic ritual abuse panic

For more than a decade, therapists, police and prosecutors across the English-speaking world pursued a conspiracy of satanic cults abusing children in daycare centres. More than twelve thousand accusations produced no corroborated case. People went to prison anyway.

Cults & Movements · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2005–2006 · United States

The Seigenthaler Wikipedia hoax

For 132 days a Wikipedia biography stated that John Seigenthaler had been suspected of involvement in both Kennedy assassinations. He had been Robert Kennedy's assistant and a pallbearer at his funeral. One man wrote it to amuse a colleague.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1856–2024 · United Kingdom

The Shakespeare authorship question

The claim that someone else wrote Shakespeare's plays began in the mid-1800s, more than two centuries after his death. The documentary record from his lifetime is ordinary and consistent, and the favoured alternative candidate died in 1604.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1994–2023 · Baltic Sea

The sinking of the MS Estonia

852 people died when a Baltic ferry sank in 1994. Claims of a deliberate sinking to hide military cargo have circulated since. A concealment did occur, and it was not that one — which is why this entry is worth reading carefully.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1880–2024 · United States

The Smithsonian and the giant skeletons

A claim that the Smithsonian destroyed thousands of giant human skeletons to protect orthodox history. Its key evidence is an invented court ruling from a fake-news site, and its supporting evidence is nineteenth-century newspapers that were selling copies.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1996–1998 · United States

The Sokal affair

A physicist submitted a paper arguing that quantum gravity is a social construct. A leading cultural-studies journal published it. He announced the same day that every scientific claim in it was invented.

Media & Technology · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2024 · United States

The Springfield pet-eating claim

A secondhand Facebook post became a line in the 2024 presidential debate within three weeks. Springfield, Ohio had no such reports. The city then received dozens of bomb threats.

Modern Internet-Era · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1780–2024 · Global

The swoon hypothesis

The claim that Jesus was taken from the cross alive and revived, with the resurrection either a misunderstanding or a staged deception. It is one of the few fringe historical claims that non-believing scholars reject as firmly as believing ones.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1995–2024 · North Atlantic

The Titanic switch theory

The claim that White Star swapped a damaged sister ship for the Titanic and sank her for insurance is answered by the wreck. The yard number stamped on the parts is Titanic's. The insurance would also have lost the company money.

Historical Cover-ups · 2 min

DEBUNKED

2017–2019 · United States

The Trump Tower wiretap allegation

A president alleged in a Saturday-morning post that his predecessor had wiretapped his building before the election. The Justice Department subsequently told a court that no such records exist. The allegation nonetheless became the seed of a longer story.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1924–1930 · United States

The Tucson artifacts

Lead crosses and swords dug out of a caliche bank near Tucson in 1924, inscribed in Latin and Hebrew with the history of a Roman colony in Arizona. There was nothing else in the ground. One of the swords has a dinosaur on it.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2022–2024 · Ukraine / Russia

The Ukrainian bioweapons laboratories

Russia told the UN Security Council that the United States operated a military biological weapons network in Ukraine. The laboratories are real and their funding is published. What they do is upgrade the security of Soviet-era pathogen collections.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1921–1975 · United Kingdom / Europe

The witch-cult hypothesis

The theory that the people executed as witches in early modern Europe were members of a real pagan religion that had survived underground since antiquity. It held the Encyclopaedia Britannica entry for forty years. It was made by selective quotation.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2007–2024 · Global

The Younger Dryas impact hypothesis

A proposal that a comet struck the northern hemisphere 12,900 years ago, ending the Clovis culture. The key evidence has not replicated. The claim that archaeology suppresses it is refuted by the literature arguing about it.

Pseudoscience · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2010–2019 · United States

Uranium One

The claim that Hillary Clinton sold a fifth of American uranium to Russia for donations. The committee that approved it has nine members, she was not the one who sat on it, and the uranium cannot legally leave the country.

Finance & Economics · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1998–2024 · Global

Vaccines and autism

The claim originates in a twelve-child study that was retracted, whose author was found to have manipulated the data and to have been paid by litigants. Cohort studies since have followed millions of children and found nothing. Measles came back anyway.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min