THE ARCHIVE

Category

Medicine & Public Health

DEBUNKED

1945–2024 · United States

Fluoridation as mind control

The claim that fluoride was added to water to pacify populations dates to 1950s anti-communist pamphleteering. The dental benefit is real and measured. The dosing question has been revised downward on evidence, which is what a health policy is supposed to do.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

UNRESOLVED

2016–2024 · Global

Havana Syndrome

US diplomats and intelligence officers reported sudden, directional sensations followed by lasting symptoms, starting in Havana in 2016. Seven years of investigation produced two credible and incompatible readings of the same case files.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2006–2023 · Global

Miracle Mineral Supplement

A solution that becomes chlorine dioxide when mixed as instructed, sold as a cure for HIV, cancer, malaria, autism and COVID-19, with the claim that regulators suppress it because it is cheap. People have died. Its distributors were convicted.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2002–2024 · United States

Morgellons

People report fibres emerging from their skin, along with crawling sensations and lesions, and are told by doctors that no infection is present. The distress is genuine and the condition is recognised clinically. What is not supported is the claim that a pathogen is being covered up.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

CONFIRMED

1950–1969 · United States

Operation Sea-Spray

In 1950 the US Navy sprayed bacteria over San Francisco from a ship offshore to model a biological attack. It was one of hundreds of open-air tests conducted over American cities for two decades. Residents were not told, then or for twenty-six years afterwards.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

CONFIRMED

1953–1973 · United States

Project MKUltra

For twenty years the CIA funded research into chemical and psychological control of human behaviour, including administering LSD to people who had not consented and did not know. Most of the files were destroyed on the director's order in 1973. What survived was enough.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

CONFIRMED

1953–1957 · Global

Project Sunshine

To measure how much fallout from nuclear testing was ending up in human bone, the Atomic Energy Commission collected thousands of tissue samples — many from dead infants — from around the world, without telling the families. The programme's own transcripts record officials discussing the difficulty of obtaining bodies.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1950–2024 · Philippines / Brazil / Global

Psychic surgery

Practitioners appear to open a patient's body with their hands, remove diseased tissue and leave no wound. The tissue is chicken. The technique is sleight of hand, and it is sold to people with terminal diagnoses.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

CONFIRMED

1994–2015 · United States / United Kingdom

Study 329

A drug trial in adolescents that failed on every one of its eight pre-specified measures was published as showing the drug was effective and well tolerated. Two million prescriptions a year followed.

Medicine & Public Health · 4 min

CONFIRMED

1929–1980 · Global

The asbestos industry cover-up

Asbestos manufacturers knew by the 1930s that their product killed the people who worked with it. They edited the medical literature, kept diagnoses from workers, and kept selling for another forty years.

Medicine & Public Health · 2 min

DEBUNKED

1981–2023 · Global

The aspartame cover-up

A chain email circulated from the 1990s attributing multiple sclerosis, lupus and blindness to a sweetener, and a corrupt approval to Donald Rumsfeld. The disease list is fabricated. The regulatory history is real, contested in public, and more interesting than the conspiracy version.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

UNRESOLVED

2019–2024 · China / Global

The COVID-19 lab-leak hypothesis

Two hypotheses remain live: that SARS-CoV-2 entered humans through the wildlife trade, and that it escaped from a laboratory in Wuhan. Serious scientists hold both positions. The decisive early evidence sits in China and has not been released.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

CONFIRMED

2017–2018 · Puerto Rico / United States

The Hurricane Maria death toll

Puerto Rico's official Hurricane Maria toll stood at 64 for eleven months. Independent researchers estimated thousands. The government fought the release of death records, lost, commissioned its own study, and revised the figure to 2,975.

Historical Cover-ups · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1951–1998 · Korea / China / Soviet Union

The Korean War biological warfare allegations

China and North Korea alleged in 1952 that the United States was dropping plague-infected insects on Korea. Captured American airmen confessed. The Soviet files record the whole thing as a fabrication and describe how it was assembled.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

CONFIRMED

2020–2022 · United States

The New York nursing home undercount

New York published a nursing home death toll that excluded residents who died after transfer to hospital. The Attorney General found the real figure was about twice as high. The administration's own aide said the data had been held back.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1992–2008 · Democratic Republic of the Congo / Global

The polio vaccine AIDS hypothesis

The claim that HIV entered humans through a polio vaccine trialled in the Congo in the late 1950s. The vaccine was tested and was clean, and the virus is older than the trial.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1980–1995 · United States / Canada / United Kingdom

The satanic ritual abuse panic

For more than a decade, therapists, police and prosecutors across the English-speaking world pursued a conspiracy of satanic cults abusing children in daycare centres. More than twelve thousand accusations produced no corroborated case. People went to prison anyway.

Cults & Movements · 3 min

CONFIRMED

1965–1980 · United States

The Sugar Research Foundation's funded science

In the 1960s a sugar industry trade group paid Harvard nutrition researchers to write a review that shifted blame for heart disease from sugar to saturated fat. The funding was not disclosed. The review shaped dietary guidance for decades.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

CONFIRMED

1953–1998 · United States

The tobacco industry's manufactured doubt

Tobacco companies knew their product caused cancer and was addictive, and spent four decades and enormous sums manufacturing public uncertainty about both. The internal documents are now searchable online because a court ordered them released.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

CONFIRMED

1932–1972 · United States

The Tuskegee Syphilis Study

For forty years the US Public Health Service followed 399 Black men with syphilis in Macon County, Alabama, without treating them — and, once penicillin became standard, worked to keep them from getting it. The study was not secret. It was published in medical journals for decades before anyone stopped it.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

2022–2024 · Ukraine / Russia

The Ukrainian bioweapons laboratories

Russia told the UN Security Council that the United States operated a military biological weapons network in Ukraine. The laboratories are real and their funding is published. What they do is upgrade the security of Soviet-era pathogen collections.

Government & Intelligence · 3 min

CONFIRMED

1936–1945 · China / Japan

Unit 731

A Japanese army unit in occupied Manchuria conducted lethal human experimentation and biological warfare on a mass scale. After the war the United States granted its senior officers immunity from prosecution in exchange for their data.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min

DEBUNKED

1998–2024 · Global

Vaccines and autism

The claim originates in a twelve-child study that was retracted, whose author was found to have manipulated the data and to have been paid by litigants. Cohort studies since have followed millions of children and found nothing. Measles came back anyway.

Medicine & Public Health · 3 min