The salamander letter
A letter that rewrote the founding story of the Latter-day Saint movement, sold to collectors and to the church itself. Its author had made it. When exposure came close he killed two people with pipe bombs.
Why this verdict
Debunked by forensic document examination and by a guilty plea: the ink had been artificially aged and cracked in a way no nineteenth-century document does, and Mark Hofmann — who forged it — admitted the forgery after killing two people to stop the discovery of it.
- Period
- Region
- Reading time
- Sources
01The claim
That a letter dated 23 October 1830, purportedly written by Martin Harris to W. W. Phelps, was an authentic early document of the Latter-day Saint movement — and that it showed Joseph Smith's discovery of the golden plates to have been mediated not by an angel but by a white salamander that transfigured itself, placing the movement's origin in the folk-magic culture of upstate New York rather than in the account the church teaches.
02Where it came from
Mark Hofmann was a dealer in early Mormon documents with an established reputation, built on a run of finds that were themselves forgeries. The salamander letter surfaced in 1984 and was bought by the document collector and businessman Steven Christensen, who donated it to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in April 1985. The church published its text. It was explosive in a very specific way: it did not fabricate an accusation, it relocated a familiar story into a documented cultural context — treasure-seeking, seer stones, folk magic — that historians already knew surrounded the young Joseph Smith. That is what made it credible, and it is the design principle behind every good forgery in this archive.
03What the record shows
✕ DEBUNKED — Investigated and refuted. Here is what actually happened.
The forgery was exposed by murder before it was exposed by science.
Hofmann had sold documents he had not yet made and owed money he could not repay. On 15 October 1985 two pipe bombs killed Steven Christensen and Kathleen Sheets, the wife of Christensen's former business partner. The following day a third bomb detonated in Hofmann's own car, severely injuring him and turning the investigation toward him.
The forensic case was then built by the document examiners George Throckmorton and William Flynn. Under magnification the ink on Hofmann's documents showed a distinctive cracking — the ink had been artificially aged with a chemical treatment, which oxidised the iron in the iron-gall formula and left a surface unlike the ageing of a genuine nineteenth-century manuscript. Flynn reconstructed the ink recipe Hofmann had used. The test, once developed, identified other Hofmann documents across collections that no one had suspected.
Hofmann pleaded guilty in January 1987 to two counts of second-degree murder and to fraud, and admitted the forgeries. He is serving a life sentence.
The church's role has been read both ways and the record does not support the stronger reading. It bought and was given documents, including damaging ones, and it published this one — behaviour consistent with an institution being deceived rather than one running a concealment. It has since published its own account of the affair.
04What it cost
The salamander letter did real historiographical damage in both directions: for two years it was cited in serious scholarship, and after the exposure a generation of genuine documents was treated with suspicion because Hofmann had contaminated the market they came from. The pattern to keep is the one this entry shares with Piltdown and the Bat Creek Stone. A forgery succeeds not by inventing something outlandish but by supplying, in physical form, the document that specialists in the field have already half-imagined — which is why the field's own experts are the last people able to catch it.